Billy Sunday

Why this bar is here

Discovery citations supporting inclusion in this guide:

1. The Infatuation
   The Best Cocktail Bars In Chicago
   May 26, 2026
2. Time Out
   The 18 best cocktail bars in Chicago
   April 14, 2026

Reviewed cocktail menu

Menu reviewed September 7, 2026. Source coverage: Complete published menu.

Coverage describes the reviewed published source. Menus may change; check the official website for current information.

1. Ranch Water

   AGAVE, WATERMELON, AMARO NONINO & ARBOL

   $14

2. Suffering Bastard

   GIN, RYE, GINGER AMARO, BASIL & BLACK PEPPER

   $14

3. Americano

   RED BITTERS, VERMOUTH, STRONG RUM & SUMMER SAVORY

   $14

4. Duke of Prunes

   SCOTCH, STONE FRUIT, CINNAMON & FINO SHERRY

   $14

5. Billy Sunday Old Fashioned

   BOURBON BLEND, RABARBARO, GOLDEN SYRUP & ORANGE OIL

   $15

6. Jungle Bird

   HOUSE RUM BLEND, BLACKSTRAP, CAMPARI, PINEAPPLE & MOLASSES

   $15

7. Amaro Daiquiri

   AMARO BLEND, RABARBARO, SIROP & LIME

   $15

8. Billy Sunday Negroni

   OLD TOM GIN, GRAN CLASSICO & VERMOUTH

   $15

9. Espresso Martini

   ELVELO REPOSADO, ALPINE AMARO, KYOTO STYLE COLD BREW & PILONCILLO

   $15

10. Chicagoan

    PUNT E MES, MALORT, GREEN KEY & LEMON

    $15

11. Vintage Vieux Carre

    WILLETT 4 YEAR RYE, L'ENCANTADA 25 YEAR CUTXAN ARMAGNAC, 1970s STREGA, 1970's CYNAR, SWEET VERMOUTH & PEYCHAUD'S

    $55

12. Vintage Pink Squirrel

    CREME DE CACAO, CREME DE NOYAUX, EARLY 2000s CAMPARI, 1980s GAMBAROTTA, 1970s CYNAR & SPICED GOAT MILK

    $35

13. Vintage Baby Darling

    FOURSQUARE MAMDANUS, 1990s FLOR DE CANA, 1970s ISOLABELLA 18 & COCCHI VDT

    $45

14. Vintage Amaro Daiquiri

    EARLY 2000s AVERNA, 1970s FERNET TONIC, SIROP & LIME

    $35

15. Bloody Mary

    VODKA, HOUSE BLOODY MARY MIX, HORSERADISH & HOUSE PICKLES

    $14

16. Billy Beer #1

    DUCK FAT WASHED MEZCAL, CLARIFIED TOMATILLOS, GREEN TOMATO, CITRUS & DOVETAIL HELLES LAGER

    $15

17. Lupine Lady

    LAVENDER AND THYME INFUSED VERJUS, LIME, MINT, BASIL & SPARKLING WATER

    $12

18. Records & Tapes

    SERVED SWEETHEART MILKSHAKE STYLE GET THIS ONE FOR DESSERT

    RYE, BLACKSTRAP, CZECH AMARO, HOUSE SARSAPARILLA, BROWN SUGAR & PEACH ICE CREAM, LEMON & CASSIS DRIZZLE

    $18

19. All Inclusive

    JUNIPER MEETS TIKI. JUICY AND SUPER FUN

    GIN, CACHACA, BANANA, JUNIPER & LEMON

    $16

20. Windy City, 9pm

    ARTURO'S TACOS, MARGIES CANDIES, A COCKTAIL

    REPOSADO, RYE, CHIPOTLE AND MUSHROOM CORDIAL, TOASTED RICE AMARO, CREME DE CACAO & PINEAPPLE

    $17

21. Valley of the Saroos

    A FLORAL SAZERAC STYLED OUT WITH HOUSE MADA AMARO

    BLENDED SCOTCH, LAVENDER, LYCHEE, NUTMEG, ANISE & BERGAMOT

    $16

22. Blood Oath

    A REFRESHING BLOOD & SAND...PEATED, BRIGHT AND A LITTLE BITTER

    SCOTCH, 3 AMARI BLEND, VERMOUTH, ACIDIFIED BLOOD ORANGE, BITTERS

    $16

23. Green Juice

    YOU COULD ARGUE THIS IS HEALTHY...DEFINITELY REFRESHING THOUGH

    GIN, GENEPY, CUCUMBER, CORIANDER, MINT, GINGER & LEMON

    $16

24. Orange Chicken

    PANDA EXPRESS MEETS MILK PUNCH

    MELETTI ANISETTE, WALNUT HONEY, DATES, SESAME OIL & MILK (CLARIFIED)

    $16

25. Mr. Rabbit

    CARROT BREAD AND BUTTER PICKLES FOR THE PATIO. EVERY LITTLE SOUL MUST SHINE.

    TURMERIC VODVA, BECHEROVKA, CARROT & MANGO SHRUB, LEMON, BLACK PEPPER & SORREL

    $16